The True Father
As it turned out, Cynthia was cheating with Eric, who got her pregnant. Cynthia was so happy because now Johnny had no case to take custody of the triplets. Plus, she already had full custody of Naomi. Though he could fight, her daughter preferred her!
Leaving Angrily
When Johnny realized he wasn’t the father, he left the hospital and Naomi. He immediately called his lawyer, asking to drop the case because he could only lose. Plus, he didn’t want kids that weren’t his. Maybe he and his new girlfriend could conceive!